Lutherans should avoid Episcopalians’ schism over homosexuality

The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (ELCA) made front page news over the weekend sanctioning, by a wide margin, gay and lesbian clergy involved in long-term relationships to serve.

Another vote at the national ELCA conference in Minneapolis is what undoubtedly gives Lutherans a necessary pause.

The body approved a social statement pledging greater recognition of gays and lesbians within the church community by one vote. By church bylaws, the statement had to pass with a two-thirds majority. It received 66.67 percent support and paved the way for the clergy vote.

Certainly division and discord exists over extending more rights to gays and lesbians. The crucial steps moving forward will be for the denomination to let cool heads prevail and avert the civil war underway in the American Episcopal Church and worldwide Anglicanism.

Starting with the ordination of openly gay New Hampshire bishop Gene Robinson in 2003, the Episcopal Church has become a fractured and contentious body. Earlier this summer the conservative Convocation of Anglicans in North America officially became a breakaway sect, launching a blatant opposition to the Episcopal Church’s loosening of views on gay clergy and gay rights.

At its convention this summer the Episcopal Church ended its self-imposed moratorium on consecrating gay bishops. Within days, dioceses in California and Minnesota accepted nominations of gay bishops to fill vacant spots.

Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams also recently announced the development of a “twin-track” structure whereby churches which don’t conform to traditional Anglican views – including on homosexuality – could be downgraded to “associate” status. This would essentially strip them of decision-making ability within the worldwide body.

Lutherans have their work cut out for them.

Their ability to reconcile differences of opinion will be essential to their survival as a denomination in its current form. If they are successful in being able to agree to disagree and still keep relative unity, they could provide an important blueprint for other Protestant denominations that will almost certainly face similar challenges in coming years as the rights homosexuals seek in society at large is played out in the church.


Be First to Comment

  1. robertroy said:

    The ELCA was already one of the fastest declining denominations. What was the fastest this year? The one that is the most liberal with respect to normalization of homosexuality, the UCC. Two questions: 1) Can a denomination remain Biblically faithful with respect to other issues yet buy into the “Gay is OK” line? 2) Can a denomination not undergo cataclysmic decline after taking the “Gay is OK” plunge? There is no evidence that both answers aren’t an unequivocal “NO”.

    August 24, 2009
  2. Monique Davis said:

    This is a hard topic. The church I attend has openly gay members actually serving in the music ministry. It’s something I have recently started being challenged on (my attendance at this church) and I have begun soul searching to see if I really do need to leave or what the best response is. I hope churches can find a way to reach gay people while remaining true to God’s call that homosexuality is a sin. Until then, we’ll all have to pray and do what God directs.

    August 25, 2009

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *